Well, let’s parallel that with Tegan And Sara’s latest Alligator LP. Apparently, remixes have reached the heights of popularity where you can now release a 17-track album, with 16 of the tracks dedicated to remixes of the same song. In this case, Alligator is dedicated completely to, well, “Alligator” off the duo’s last album, Sainthood. And I guess when you enlist the help of heavy-hitters like Passion Pit, Holy Fuck, Four Tet, Toro Y Moi, and Ra Ra Riot, you can do that, and it’s okay. The scariest part, though, is that if I were to be compiling a top tracks you should download list, I might even include three of the remixes off of Alligator on that list. That’s how good these remixes are — well, some of them, anyway.
The remixes on Alligator cover a lot of musical ground, for sure; that’s probably the only way such an LP is possible in the first place. But even with the diversity, it gets a little boring to sit through in its entirety. Who cares, though? I’m convinced the purpose of an album such as this is not purely the album’s standalone quality, but rather its potential to be viral. If used correctly, it can give individuals who might never have been interested in Tegan And Sara before the unique opportunity of latching onto remixes by other artists they respect. If I were Sire Records, what I would do is offer absolutely all of the MP3’s for free, with each MP3 featured on a different outlet so that fans really have to peck and hunt to find the whole album. As a result, they’d be spending a good portion of their time focused on Tegan And Sara, resulting in an interesting Easter egg hunt of sorts (and what good timing for that, too!). The name Tegan And Sara would be permanently stuck in their head, and the act of listening to the remixes would be rendered that much more special. But that’s just me, and I digress. Let’s talk about the music.
Holy Fuck and Passion Pit’s remixes start the album off with an ’80s vibe — one which reemerges here and there throughout Alligator. Other remixers take a more traditional electronic route, with VHS Or Beta’s remix verging on club trance cheesiness, Hi-Deaf’s remix harboring an underlying beat a bit reminiscent of the opening of “Funkytown,” and Morgan Page’s remix wholly embracing house beats.
Standouts, in my book, include the Holy Fuck opener, as well as Four Tet’s minimalistic take, Ra Ra Riot’s airy manipulation, and Dave Sitek’s quirky offering. There are other noteworthy submissions, including the trancey Kevin St. Croix remix, and Sara’s original lo-fi demo of “Alligator” is a welcome reprieve from all the bells and whistles found on the rest of the album. Still, though, I’m way too tired of writing about the same song to continue listing out the details of each individual remix. Alligator is a recommended listen; even if the whole thing isn’t appealing to you, at least parts of it will be.